Why Hilton Head Short-Term Rental Owners Benefit from the STR Loophole

About Donna Gilmore

Donna Gilmore is the Director of Operations for COAST, the #1 eXp real estate team in South Carolina. She specializes in Hilton Head short-term rental properties and helps investors maximize returns through strategic tax planning and property optimization. Schedule an STR Strategy Consultation →

Related Articles

• → How to Qualify for STR Non-Passive Status in 2026
• → Cost Segregation Case Studies for Hilton Head Investors
• → The Best Seasons to Buy or Sell on Hilton Head Island

# Why Hilton Head Short-Term Rental Owners Benefit from the STR Loophole (2026 Tax Strategy Guide)

If you own—or plan to buy—a short-term rental (STR) property in Hilton Head or Bluffton, the STR loophole is one of the most powerful tax strategies available. It can allow you to use depreciation to offset W-2 income, 1099 income, business income, or commissions—something long-term rentals cannot normally do.

This guide explains how the STR loophole works, how Hilton Head’s tourism patterns make qualifying easier, and how investors can combine this with cost segregation for substantial year-one tax savings.

What Is the STR Loophole?

Simple definition: The STR loophole lets you treat a short-term rental as a non-passive activity if you meet certain IRS participation rules. This allows depreciation losses—including cost segregation—to offset active income.

To qualify, your property must meet the IRS definition of a short-term rental:

• The average guest stay is 7 days or fewer, OR
• The average stay is less than 30 days AND you provide substantial services.

Most Hilton Head STRs naturally meet the 7-day rule due to weekly vacation patterns, making this market especially STR-friendly.

Why the STR Loophole Matters for Hilton Head Investors

Hilton Head stands out for STR investors because:

• Weekly rentals dominate the island’s spring & summer seasons
• Guests expect strong amenities, which increase STR revenue
• Seasonal demand supports high occupancy & ADR
• Renovations often qualify for accelerated depreciation

These factors make qualifying for STR non-passive status significantly easier compared to less active STR markets.

How to Qualify for STR Non-Passive Status

You only need to meet ONE of these IRS participation tests:

1. 100 Hours + More Time Than Anyone Else

You qualify if:

• You spend at least 100 hours per year managing the STR
• You spend more time than cleaners, handymen, or managers

This is the most common path for Hilton Head STR owners—especially those who self-manage guest communication, pricing, and turnovers.

2. 500+ Hours

This applies if you are heavily involved in:

• Guest communication
• Pricing strategy
• Maintenance coordination
• Turnover scheduling
• Marketing the listing

3. You Do “Substantially All” of the Work

This applies if you manage virtually everything yourself.

How the STR Loophole Reduces Taxes

If your STR qualifies as non-passive, you can use depreciation—and especially bonus depreciation from cost segregation—to offset:

• W-2 salary
• 1099 contractor income
• Business income
• Commission income
• Capital gains in some scenarios

Unlike long-term rentals, STRs do not require you to be a full-time real estate professional to unlock these benefits.

Hilton Head Example: The STR Loophole in Action

Here’s an example of a Hilton Head STR property using cost segregation:

• Purchase price: $750,000
• Annual STR income: $135,000–$165,000
• Bonus depreciation (via cost seg): ~$135,000

If the STR qualifies as non-passive, that depreciation can offset:

• W-2 income
• Commission income
• Business income

At a 30% tax rate, that’s roughly $40,000 in tax savings in year one.

Why Hilton Head Makes STR Qualification Easier

Hilton Head’s rental patterns align naturally with IRS rules because:

• Weekly stays are the norm
• Demand is year-round for families, golfers, and snowbirds
• Self-management is more common than in other coastal markets
• Renovated properties produce stronger depreciation opportunities

This combination makes Hilton Head one of the strongest STR loophole markets in the Southeast.

What About Real Estate Professional Status (REPS)?

REPS is a different, more complex tax designation. It can unlock similar tax benefits but requires:

• 750+ hours per year in real estate activities
• More than half of your total working time in real estate

The STR loophole is often the more achievable path for high-income earners who cannot meet REPS requirements.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Hilton Head allow STRs?

Most resort communities do, but rules vary by POA/HOA. Always verify local regulations before purchasing.

Can STR depreciation offset my W-2 income?

Yes—if your STR qualifies as a non-passive activity.

Do I need to self-manage?

You must materially participate. Many owners self-manage messaging, pricing, and turnovers while outsourcing cleaning.

Does this work on second homes?

Yes, as long as the property is rented at least 14 days per year and meets STR rules.

Ready to See If You Qualify for the STR Loophole?

I help Hilton Head investors determine whether they qualify for STR non-passive status and how to combine it with cost segregation for powerful tax savings.

Want a personalized STR tax strategy? I can run your property numbers and walk you through next steps.

Disclaimer

This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute financial, tax, or legal advice. Please consult a qualified CPA or attorney for guidance on your specific situation.

About the Author

By: Donna Gilmore – Realtor & Director of Operations for the #1 eXp Team in South Carolina

Expert Real Estate Mentor & Team Transition Specialist | AI Systems Strategist for Top-Producing Agents & Teams | Creator of the Systems-to-Scale AI Implementation Method™

Helping agents, teams, and leaders implement AI, automation, and high-performance systems to grow smarter, scale faster, and dominate their markets.